When the Limit Breaks

This scene separates pointwise from uniform convergence. Watch the power curves break in the limit.

Pointwise convergence waits at each point separately. Uniform convergence moves the whole interval at once. If even one point holds out forever, convergence is not uniform. That is how a limit of continuous curves can break.

For example, picture πŸ§‘ classmates in a row sitting down together. It counts as done only when everyone is seated. If one classmate stays standing, the row as a whole is not finished.

fn(x)=xn→f(x)={0x<11x=1f_n(x)=x^n\to f(x)=\begin{cases}0&x<1\\1&x=1\end{cases}
sup⁑[0,1]∣fnβˆ’f∣=1β†’ΜΈ0\sup_{[0,1]}|f_n-f|=1\not\to 0

Part of these learning paths

Examples & Exercises

Find the pointwise limit of fn(x)=xnf_n(x) = x^n on [0,1][0,1]: prove it equals 00 on [0,1)[0,1) and 11 at x=1x = 1.

f(x)={00≀x<11x=1f(x) = \begin{cases} 0 & 0 \leq x < 1 \\ 1 & x = 1 \end{cases}
n=8n = 8 β€” the curve hugs 00, then shoots up at x=1x = 1.
Show proof
  1. At x=1x = 1, fn(1)=1n=1f_n(1) = 1^n = 1 for every nn, so the limit is 11.

  2. At x=0x = 0 the limit is trivially 00. For 0<x<10 < x < 1, write t=1x>1t = \frac1x > 1 as t=1+ht = 1 + h with h>0h > 0; Bernoulli's inequality gives tnβ‰₯1+nht^n \geq 1 + nh.

    Hence 0≀xn=1tn≀11+nhβ†’00 \leq x^n = \frac{1}{t^n} \leq \frac{1}{1+nh} \to 0, so xnβ†’0x^n \to 0 by the squeeze theorem.

  3. The pointwise limit is therefore 00 on [0,1)[0,1) and 11 at x=1x = 1 β€” discontinuous at x=1x = 1. A first warning that pointwise limits of continuous functions need not be continuous.

Prove sup⁑[0,1]∣fnβˆ’f∣=1\sup_{[0,1]} |f_n - f| = 1 for every nn, and conclude the convergence is not uniform.

sup⁑[0,1]∣fnβˆ’f∣=1β†’ΜΈ0\sup_{[0,1]} |f_n - f| = 1 \not\to 0
n=8n = 8, Ξ΅=0.2\varepsilon = 0.2 β€” the chart reads β‰ˆ0.98\approx 0.98 on its grid; the exact supremum is 11 (never attained).
Show proof
  1. On [0,1)[0,1), ∣fnβˆ’f∣=xn|f_n - f| = x^n, and it is 00 at x=1x = 1, so sup⁑[0,1]∣fnβˆ’f∣=sup⁑[0,1)xn\sup_{[0,1]} |f_n - f| = \sup_{[0,1)} x^n.

  2. Since xn<1x^n < 1 for x<1x < 1, the supremum is at most 11. But xnβ†’1x^n \to 1 as xβ†’1βˆ’x \to 1^{-} (continuity of the power function), so no number below 11 is an upper bound.

    The supremum is exactly 11.

  3. Uniform convergence would require sup⁑∣fnβˆ’fβˆ£β†’0\sup |f_n - f| \to 0, but here it equals 11 for every nn. Hence (xn)(x^n) does not converge uniformly.

Prove that a uniformly convergent sequence of continuous functions has a continuous limit β€” the Ξ΅/3\varepsilon/3 argument.

∣f(x)βˆ’f(x0)βˆ£β‰€Ξ΅3+Ξ΅3+Ξ΅3=Ξ΅|f(x) - f(x_0)| \leq \tfrac{\varepsilon}{3} + \tfrac{\varepsilon}{3} + \tfrac{\varepsilon}{3} = \varepsilon
n=30n = 30 β€” for xnx^n, no NN works for all xx at once. Uniform convergence is exactly that simultaneity.
Show proof
  1. Let each fnf_n be continuous and fn→ff_n \to f uniformly. Fix x0x_0 and Ρ>0\varepsilon > 0.

  2. By uniform convergence there is NN with sup⁑∣fNβˆ’f∣<Ξ΅3\sup |f_N - f| < \frac{\varepsilon}{3}. Fix this NN.

  3. Since fNf_N is continuous at x0x_0, there is Ξ΄>0\delta > 0 with ∣fN(x)βˆ’fN(x0)∣<Ξ΅3|f_N(x) - f_N(x_0)| < \frac{\varepsilon}{3} whenever ∣xβˆ’x0∣<Ξ΄|x - x_0| < \delta.

  4. For ∣xβˆ’x0∣<Ξ΄|x - x_0| < \delta, the triangle inequality gives ∣f(x)βˆ’f(x0)βˆ£β‰€βˆ£f(x)βˆ’fN(x)∣+∣fN(x)βˆ’fN(x0)∣+∣fN(x0)βˆ’f(x0)∣<Ξ΅3+Ξ΅3+Ξ΅3=Ξ΅|f(x) - f(x_0)| \leq |f(x) - f_N(x)| + |f_N(x) - f_N(x_0)| + |f_N(x_0) - f(x_0)| < \frac{\varepsilon}{3} + \frac{\varepsilon}{3} + \frac{\varepsilon}{3} = \varepsilon. So ff is continuous at x0x_0, and x0x_0 was arbitrary.

4. Continuity